So the doctor says to the average patient, “The government rationing board has banned the drug that would treat your prostate cancer and extend your life by several months because it is too expensive. I am sorry, but good luck.” This patient goes home to his family and relays the news and as good citizens all accept the “decision” because as we all know the government knows best.
The same doctor informs the richest man in the world the same news and then says, ” You can get this drug in the U.S. if you are willing to pay for it and fly there to get it. I might even find a private clinic here in the U.K. that may supply you with the medicine if you will pay for it and if you receiving it is approved by the NICE rationing board. Do you know any of the members of the board? A word here or there may be of benefit to you. If I can be any help at all Mr. Buffet please let me know. With your resources I am sure that we can reach a suitable resolution to this pesky issue.”
Mr. Buffet says to his associate as he is leaving the doctor’s office, ” Call my contact in New York and set this treatment up for me ASAP.”
Obamacare, NHS, Rationing boards, NICE…Fineberg Iceberg its all the same to me.
I recently read a historical account of the relationship of England and Ireland and how back in the day the Irish were harshly treated and many of their rights were abridged by the English. A rule of having to give up your house or a horse by an Irishman if an Englishman wanted it comes to mind. I found the sentence at the end of this piece odd, that the drug alluded to was “banned” in Scotland. Banned? Really? Why Scotland?
Mr. Cass enlighten me. The U.K. is England, Wales, Scotland, and Ireland. Why is Ireland not mentioned?
Prostate drug ban lifted as NICE U-turn gives cancer sufferers chance of longer life
By Jenny Hope
PUBLISHED: 19:46 EST, 13 May 2012 | UPDATED: 20:15 EST, 13 May 2012
The NHS rationing body is poised to reverse a proposed ban on a drug that will give precious months of extra life to men with advanced prostate cancer.
The U-turn is a victory for the Daily Mail, which has fought for years for better care for prostate cancer sufferers, and follows a campaign by the Prostate Cancer Charity and a rare intervention by the Department of Health.
Abiraterone – which costs £3,000 for a month’s treatment – was judged too expensive by the National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence.
But now the drug will be the first specific treatment for the disease approved for use on the NHS for more than a decade.
Experts say it is stark evidence of the neglect of those who suffer from a disease that strikes 40,000 British men each year.
Abiraterone is one of two new drugs proved to prolong survival when other treatments have failed. The other, cabazitaxel, was banned for NHS use last week.
Trials show that men taking abiraterone and a steroid survived for nearly 15 months, while those given steroid treatment and a ‘dummy’ pill lived for 11 months on average.
But some patients live far longer than expected, including Britons who have survived on the drug for almost five years with advanced disease. Abiraterone is widely believed to have kept Lockerbie bomber Abdelbaset Al Megrahi alive.
The pill, taken four times a day, also eases pain and improves quality of life.
The plan to ban the drug was adopted by NICE despite protests that it failed to use the correct criteria to assess it.
Cancer specialists said it should have been assessed under the end-of-life system in which NICE is supposed to give weight to the value of a few extra months for terminally ill patients.
The outcry was led by the Prostate Cancer Charity, while Department of Health officials asked NICE to ‘carefully’ reconsider its proposal.
The rationing body is expected to announce this week that it will approve the drug using end-of-life criteria.
It also looked at data from the Cancer Drugs Fund, which gives patients in England access to treatments that are hard to obtain on the NHS, suggesting it is the second most popular drug, after Avastin for bowel cancer.
Around 3,300 British men with advanced prostate cancer that has become resistant to standard hormone treatments could benefit each year from abiraterone.
The drug, manufactured by Janssen, was developed by UK scientists at the Institute of Cancer Research and trials were partly funded by British charities.
Owen Sharp of the Prostate Cancer Charity said its campaign had been supported by patients and MPs appalled at the prospect of a drug available in other EU countries being banned here.
He said: ‘It was the wrong decision. This breakthrough drug will make a real difference to men with prostate cancer at the end of life who have no alternative – this is the only hope they have.
‘It gives them significant extra months of life. It also gives a huge reduction in pain. Disagreement over cost was not a reason to deny it to patients.’
Professor Jonathan Waxman, a prostate cancer specialist at Imperial College London, said the proposal to ban abiraterone was based on false cost estimates and had ignored end-of-life criteria meant to apply to such drugs.
He added: ‘The ban should be reversed because it would limit what we as clinicians can do for our patients and their families.’
NICE’s decision will affect patients in England and Wales. The drug is banned for use on the NHS in Scotland, but the decision will be reviewed.