The Decision, a prostate cancer book by a urologist who’s a patient- A book review. Good or bad?

I love the part about, ” McHugh got the name of his surgeon from a traveling salesman.”  Too funny!

Well, the book is about making a decision about what to do…not who will do it. It turns out my drug rep was right on. 

The US Review of Books


The Decision: Your prostate biopsy shows cancer... Now What?
by Dr. John C. McHugh
Jennie Cooper Press
reviewed by Carolyn Davis

“The newly diagnosed prostate cancer patient… needs to know what is pertinent and specific to him in making a decision on how to treat it.”

A urologist, McHugh, was inspired to write this informative book after he developed prostate cancer and dealt with treatment options as a patient. Part guidebook, part autobiography, it is intended for men who are facing the often perplexing choices of potential treatments.

McHugh encourages men to begin regular rectal and prostate examinations in middle age, and cites examples of patients who developed cancer well before age 50. The ‘big three’ examinations that he recommends are a test for Prostate Specific Antigen (PSA), the rectal exam, and a biopsy report. The author uses various charts, including a “McHugh Decision Worksheet,” that surveys a man in ten categories to help him to determine if he is a “radiation type,” a “surgery type,” or “undecided.” Diagrams illustrate and define the different types of prostate cancer, specific locations of cancer within the prostate, the options for treatment, and each option’s likely effects and side effects.

The doctor describes many of his personal experiences as a patient, for example “I did not get good vibes from the urologist I spoke to initially in Atlanta… he repeated, an inordinate amount of times, how many of the procedures he had performed. … Remember, a lot of this decision process [for the patient] is a gut feel.” Ultimately, McHugh found the surgeon he used through the recommendation of a visiting pharmaceutical representative.

“Prostate stories” and more of McHugh’s autobiography complete the book. The Decision is recommended for its combination of empirical tools, personal anecdotes, and overall compassion.

One Reply to “The Decision, a prostate cancer book by a urologist who’s a patient- A book review. Good or bad?”

  1. I highly recommend it for men and their partners who have to make treatment decisions in order to beat prostate cancer.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: